Fishing Real Estate

Shelter Island attracts those that ‘search some kind of quietude,’ actual property agent says


Lengthy Island’s North and South Fork are like two arms reaching round Shelter Island, says the city’s supervisor, Gary Gerth.

As one of many islands located between the 2 forks, Gerth says Shelter Island attracts its title from being “an island sheltered by islands.” With that comes a peaceable and tranquil setting and a boating and fishing haven, he says.

This Shelter Island ranch, for $699,000, includes two
This Shelter Island ranch, for $699,000, contains two bedrooms and one rest room. Picture Credit score: Douglas Elliman Actual Property

“Individuals say as quickly as you get on the ferry, your blood stress drops, and it looks like trip time,” says resident Penelope Moore of Saunders & Associates.

The 12-square-mile city, which incorporates Shelter Island and Shelter Island Heights, has a year-round inhabitants of roughly 2,500 residents, Gerth says. That quantity reaches round 12,000 in the course of the summer season months, he provides, as residents reap the benefits of the island’s choices. Newsday reported in April that Shelter Island officers had been contemplating modifications to the city’s short-term rental regulation, which requires a city license and two-week buffer between stays, to assist residents who depend upon summer season rental earnings.

Surrounded by Shelter Island Sound and Gardiners Bay, Shelter Island is residence to seashores, inns, eateries and the two,000-plus-acre Mashomack Protect, which accounts for almost one-third of the island’s land mass and provides excursions, actions and trails.

Gerth says there’s a proposal so as to add bike paths to either side of Route 114, the island’s predominant thoroughfare. He says the Historic Society, which hosts numerous occasions, underwent a latest renovation, including a 2,800-square-foot historical past middle with area for displays, places of work and interactive academic applications. Shelter Island is also residence to the Sylvester Manor Instructional Farm, whose historic windmill is at present being restored, and the Pearlman Music Program, which provides musical coaching to younger string gamers and hosts free summer season concert events. Motels within the space, amongst others, embrace The Pridwin, The Chequit and Sundown Seashore Lodge, which includes a restaurant, bar and boutique.

Get the Actual Property publication!

The most effective LI actual property information in your inbox weekly.

By clicking Enroll, you comply with our privateness coverage.

“Individuals search some kind of quietude on Shelter Island, however on the identical time there are actions,” Gerth says. He provides that the island is self-sufficient, with shops, a library, a medical middle and different necessities. “You don’t have to depart the island in the event you don’t wish to,” Gerth says. “Nevertheless it’s additionally an important springboard to completely different areas.”

Ferry service provides easy accessibility from Shelter Island to the vineyards of the North Fork and the Hamptons on the South Fork.

“You might be in the midst of the perfect of each forks,” Moore says.

This Shelter Island ranch on the market for

This Shelter Island ranch on the market for
This Shelter Island ranch available on the market for $749,000 in Could 2019, contains three bedrooms and two bogs.  Picture Credit score: Brown Harris Stevens

The island — which additionally contains Ram Island, Little Ram Island, and the integrated village of Dering Harbor — provides quite a lot of housing types, from ranches to waterfront Victorians, Moore says. Costs, she provides, can vary from round $600,000 to as a lot as $10 million. Due to Shelter Island’s seclusion and inhabitants, Moore says, “all people is aware of all people, and that makes it particular.”


There are not any condos or co-ops available on the market.


This Shelter Island farmhouse, for $899,000, includes three

This Shelter Island farmhouse, for $899,000, includes three
This Shelter Island farmhouse, for $899,000, contains three bedrooms and 2-1/2 bogs. Picture Credit score: Daniel Gale Sotheby’s Worldwide Realty

Between April 1, 2018, and Could 16, 2019, there have been 14 residence gross sales with a median sale value of $1,062,250, in line with the A number of Itemizing Service of Lengthy Island. The low value for that interval was $700,000 and the excessive was $four million. Throughout that point interval a 12 months earlier, there have been 12 residence gross sales with a median sale value of $1,305,000. The worth vary was $584,900 to $2.85 million.


City Shelter Island

Space Shelter Island, 6.5 sq. miles; Shelter Island Heights, 5.four sq. miles

ZIP code 11964, 11965

Inhabitants Shelter Island, 1,333; Heights, 1,048

Median age Shelter Island, 48.2; Heights,

Median family earnings Shelter Island, $110,148; Heights, $120,787

Median residence worth $999,500*

LIRR to NYC from Greenport, 2 hours 50 minutes at peak

Month-to-month ticket $500

College district Shelter Island

SOURCES: 2010 Census;; LIRR;

*Primarily based on gross sales up to now six months, in line with MLSLI


$727,000, Saint Mary’s Street

Fashion Farmhouse

Bedrooms three

Bogs 2 full, 1 half

Constructed 1908

Lot dimension zero.71 acres

Taxes $four,721

Elevated $77,100

Days available on the market 106

$999,500, Sunshine Street

Fashion Farmhouse

Bedrooms four

Bogs three

Built 2013

Lot dimension zero.92 acres

Taxes $four,500

Lowered $195,500

Days available on the market 83

$1.98 million, Tarkettle Street

Fashion Up to date

Bedrooms four

Bogs 5 full, 1 half

Constructed 2001

Lot dimension 1.1 acres

Taxes $11,605

Lowered $315,000

Days available on the market 236



This ranch, on a 2.2-acre property, contains two bedrooms and one rest room. It includes a lounge, formal eating room and eat-in kitchen. The property has two indifferent garages that complete 1,221 sq. toes and might maintain as much as 5 automobiles. Taxes: $three,030. Christine Beckwith, Douglas Elliman Actual Property, 631-365-6091


This ranch, with three bedrooms and two bogs, has an open flooring plan that includes a lounge with a fire, kitchen and eating space, plus a household room and an en suite master suite. The half-acre property contains an hooked up 2 1/2-car storage. Taxes: $2,813. Barbara Brundige, Brown Harris Stevens, 516-242-7878


This farmhouse, with three bedrooms and a pair of 1/2 bogs, includes a lounge with a stone hearth, an eat-in kitchen with chrome steel home equipment, and a first-floor main bedroom. The home, on a zero.97-acre lot, additionally features a screened porch, basement and hooked up two-car storage. Taxes: $four,703. Debra Von Brook Binder, Daniel Gale Sotheby’s Worldwide Realty, 631-872-2889

On A number of Listings

Variety of homes 9

Worth vary $699,000 to $three.199 million

Tax vary $2,813 to $11,261

Mike Gavin has labored at Newsday since 2007, protecting every thing from actual property to sports activities. Born and raised on Lengthy Island, he’s a graduate of Stony Brook College.

wordpress autoblog
amazon autoblog
affiliate autoblog
wordpress web site
web site improvement

Show More

Related Articles